Browse our latest issue here or download the PDF version here.
Recently, I made a trip downtown to a certain retro dance club with a few friends for a night of drinking and good old-fashioned debauchery. Like any university students after a long midterm week of sleepless nights, we were all ready to order a round (or three) of tequila shots and altogether forget about the pressures of the world of academia as we retire to a place you can stand for one night only.
Unfortunately for us, we were about to encounter one of the most notoriously loathed demons of city nightlife: the dance club bouncer. These lecherous beasts aren’t found at every bar, but meeting one usually leaves you feeling violated in one way or another. In this case, a member of our group was held up and harassed by one of these creatures, who refused to let her into the bar because he claimed her ID wasn’t legitimate. Despite the fact that she held perfectly valid Alberta government identification (bearing her photo, signature, and proof that she was indeed over the age of 18), he continued to insist that she couldn’t be allowed into the club. The problem? My friend’s ID is an Aboriginal status card.
The bouncer informed us that status cards weren’t accepted based on some mysterious bar policy, having experienced “problems” with them in the past. He claimed the government office that issues the cards is full of corruption, and as a result, the IDs are usually counterfeit. Having provided this ID at various bars, restaurants, and liquor stores numerous times without any mention of this so-called policy before, she was at a bit of a loss, and frankly, so were we. What was this guy talking about?
As he kept insisting that my friend wouldn’t be allowed in the club, it became pretty clear that his lame excuses about her ID were nothing but lies intended to cover up the fact that he was simply a world-class jackass. After finally openly admitting that he just didn’t like her and the “problems” apparently associated with her “community,” it dawned on us — the bar policy this guy was enforcing was essentially racism.
Certain clubs in Edmonton have signs posted right on their front doors proclaiming in giant capital letters, “Ed Hardy clothes not allowed in.” This odd type of discrimination against certain designer clothing brands is not only openly accepted by most people, but also generally agreed upon as a good idea. Apparently, the association particular fashion lines have with acting like a preppy douchebag is so strong that it provides grounds to actually deny a person entry into a drinking establishment. And that’s fine — plenty of bars choose to enforce dress codes. If they don’t feel like granting admittance to guys decked out in trucker hats or shirts with bedazzled skulls and tigers all over them, that’s their prerogative.
However, the buck stops there — dress code does not apply to the colour of someone’s skin. It’s undeniable that, as with clothing brands, there are negative stereotypes associated with virtually every ethnicity out there, but that clearly doesn’t make it okay to deny someone the respect they deserve, at a bar or otherwise.
It’s always hard to understand the realities of discrimination until they slap you right in the face. Most of us have been taught from a young age about the intolerant ways of the past, but few of us recognize that they are still relevant issues in the 21st century. In the end, none of this is really about being allowed into some stupid club (which, incidentally, lost the business of just about everyone I know after that night). When racism appears in our everyday lives, no matter how minor the incident may seem, we all have a responsibility to talk about it. If we can’t do that, people like our friend the bouncer are allowed to get away with whatever they want, and decades of improvements in human rights are reversed.
The kind of stuff that
By ScottThe kind of stuff that happened to your friend is illegal. Although this wouldn't be in the jurisdiction of the Gateway news section, you should go public to a mainstream news outlet (ie. CTV, The Journal), and name the bar in question. I wouldn't want to go to a bar that had this kind of policy. This kind of stuff should be stopped.
It's not illegal, though,
By NatashaIt's not illegal, though, because he let her into the bar in the end. However, I do agree that this story and the issues surfacing from it should definitely be made more public.
As a bouncer I'm dismayed to
By Edward CullensAs a bouncer I'm dismayed to learn that we are the "loathed demons of city nightlife". Our job is to keep potential problems out of clubs, if the bouncer felt that she was a potential problem he had every right to keep her out of the club. This article is opinionated garbage; I will be contacting the Gateway editor.
Bouncer for the Power
By JasonAlthough not every bouncer will abuse his position, I would say most (and I only experience this in western canadian cities for some reason) are power hungry losers facing serious psychological problems. In fact, a couple weeks ago I made a trip down to probably this same retro dance lounge. I was meeting up with some friends for a birthday, and the bouncer decided he had a problem with a bathroom product in my pocket. After he explained his "reasoning" I said thats not a problem, just give it back to me when I leave. For some reason he said it had to go in the garbage "because every item is accounted for on the cameras." I said, "great, it will account for you giving it back," but of course that didnt work for him.
Re: Edward
By RalphOpinionated garbage? I'm not surprised to see that a bouncer doesn't have the faculties to comprehend what section of the paper he's reading.
And Jason is right; bouncers are pathetic sociopaths who can't be cops or soldiers because they abuse drugs and steroids, they have diagnosed mental illnesses, criminal records, no education and a host of other issues. The article was far too kind to them, if anything.
In my opinion as a student
By DallasIn defence of bouncers everywhere, they are not all as bad as some of you are portraying them. Some are university or college students working part-time. Others are taking a break from the education life and others just like the job. I know some places that have excellent staff (including bouncers) and others, from experience that do not. This retro lounge which I also beleive have frequented once before is one of those places with unfriendly staff. The bouncer did not like my appereance that night and puched me to the side and let others in before me while I emptied my pocket. Then the staff at the coat check charged me an excessive amount to check in a bag that I was not allowed to bring into the bar even if I gave consent to the staff to look inside.
This specific situation described in the article goes much farther than rude bouncers, this is clearly racism and I would make this public and even see what you can do legal issues. You might not win, but the media will open other potential customers eyes and they might come forward with bad stories too.
Other side of the story
By Josef CheckelOther side of the story please. Was the retro-lounge contacted about the altercation? I'd like to see a statement from the bar. I think an evaluation of liquor-establishment hiring, and employee conduct regulation policies would definitely be much more effective and interesting reading than an apparent deep-seated resentment for an individual which in turn has lead to a crass generalization of the occupation itself. Good day.
Double standards
By SubCIsn't the granting of a special Aboriginal status by itself an act of racism ? If certain people feel no compunctions about getting privileges (such as no GST) on account of their birth, maybe they should not complain when it blows up on their face ? And for the record, I am an english-speaking proud Canadian of East Indian/ Bangladeshi origins, not some white supremacist. I think in this day and age, it is time to move beyond race/ ethnic identities and treat everyone (and be treated) equally.
Let's Deal With This Already.
By AutoprotolysisSomeone submit the name of the bloody institution to a local news outlet already, and get the jackass fired. The SOB doesn't deserve that job, and if the club itself holds that policy, it might as well receive a nice round of bad publicity and be shut down.
I've had many conversations with various bouncers, and while some were incredibly power-drunk assholes, most of them were guys just trying to make a living 'til they could get something better. I'm not gonna say that all bouncers are saints, just that they should be judged on an individual basis and not a prejudiced assumption. Otherwise, you're just like the jackass that set this whole discussion off.
Stupidity at its best
By JohnAs an aboriginal person I to have experienced this type of racism many times to count. on the Alberta AGLC website it has a section on there about what constitutes valid ID for going to a bar and in the section for valid proof of PRIMARY ID is indian status card. A birth certificate can be used as a secondary proof of ID but cannot be used as primary ID. Now I have been to pubs before and been refused entry strictly on the basis of being native, and one bouncer had told me that it is because native people are all alcoholics. This statement really is based upon racial sterotyping thanks to mass media and social preceptions based upon what mass media presents as facts. Not all native people are alcoholics at all but thanks to media and coverage of alcoholism in native communities it gives that exact impression. It is unfortunate for native people that they still face these racist bullshit on a daily level. . I personally think people should be more proactive in the area of racism and what to do to stomp it out. Go to places and learn about another culture right here on our campus there is the Aboriginal Student Council, open for all students not just the native ones, how about the asian students on campus etc, why not go visit and learn something new, Canada likes to say how multicultural it is show people that it is true.
In response to Double Standards
By LuluIt's excellent that you identity your cultural origins within your response which completely contradicts your statement. Being proud of your country should mean being proud of its heritage, indigenous population included. SubC, your statement is incredibly offensive. Trying to mend the gap in Socioeconomics between Aboriginals and the rest of the population is not reason for those who benefit from such action to have anything "blow up in their face." We don't live in a melting pot, and being part of your culture is important. A status card may hold benefits, but maybe you should take some time to research them further. Statistically, Aboriginal people have a higher incarceration rate, lower rate of income, and lower rate of education. The goal of Indian and Northern affairs is to correct this Socioeconomic gap. It would be ideal to believe everyone is born equal, as we all all born equal beings. However, we are not born into equal situations. Life isn't fair but we can always make attempts to correct it.
Post new comment